How to choose climbing shoes

Choose in this order: fit, then shape, then size.

  1. Fit: the shoe should be snug, with no dead space at the toes. Your toes should be flat or slightly curled, and the heel shouldn't press painfully on your Achilles.
  2. Shape: match it to your climbing. Neutral shoes suit beginners and long routes, moderate shoes suit sport and gym climbing, and aggressive shoes suit steep ground.
  3. Size: follow the brand's own rule. Brands disagree: La Sportiva, which sizes in European sizes, advises two to three sizes below your street size for soft, sensitive or aggressive shoes and one to two for trad shoes, while Evolv says its shoes aren't designed to be downsized.

We don't test or rank shoes, and this page has no affiliate links. It sets out the criteria and what manufacturers themselves say, so you can judge any shoe you try on.

Quick picker: what to look for by climbing type

You mostly climb Shape Closure Sole How tight
Your first months, in a gym or outdoors Neutral (flat) Strap for easy on and off, or laces Thicker (about 4–5.5 mm) Snug, not painful
Long trad or multi-pitch routes Neutral, often lace-up Laces, so you can loosen them between pitches or for the walk-off Thicker, stiffer Comfortable enough to wear for hours
Sport routes and gym climbing Moderate (slightly downturned) Strap or laces Thinner, stickier rubber Snugger
Bouldering and overhangs Aggressive (downturned, asymmetric) Strap Thinner (about 3–4 mm), stickier Tightest. Usually worn for one pitch or problem at a time
Thin cracks, training Varies by model Slipper (elastic, no laces or strap) Thin Snug

Sources: REI Expert Advice (shapes, closures, sole thickness); Ocún (beginners).

The length of the route is one of the best clues. All-day climbs need a shoe you can keep on. Short, hard problems reward a tighter, more downturned shoe that you take off between attempts.

Fit checks

Run these checks on every shoe you try, whatever the brand:

Sources: REI; Ocún; La Sportiva.

Size by brand: what each manufacturer says

There is no sizing standard for climbing shoes. The same number fits differently from brand to brand, and even between models from one brand. So start from the brand's own rule:

Brand Its own rule Source
La Sportiva Soft, sensitive or aggressive shoes: "two to three sizes smaller" than your street size, though La Sportiva says that isn't absolute. Trad shoes: one to two sizes under your street size La Sportiva USA help centre (the rule); La Sportiva sizing and technology page (the European half-size scale)
Scarpa Climbing shoes: downsize by ½ to 2 sizes from your measured size, depending on preference and use Scarpa fit tool (PDF)
Evolv "Evolv shoes are not designed to be downsized." Max Performance fit: your street size. Performance: street size plus 0.5 to 1.0. Comfort: street size plus 1.0 to 1.5 Evolv product pages; REI listings quoting Evolv
Evolv (current sizing page) Beginner: two sizes larger than your street size. Intermediate: one size larger. Advanced: your street size. If unsure, one size larger evolvsports.com/sizing
Ocún Beginners: start at your regular street size. Advanced climbers try smaller, more technical shoes Ocún

Evolv publishes two scales. Its product pages say "comfort" is plus 1.0 to 1.5 sizes, while its current sizing page says plus 2 for a beginner fit. Check the guide on the page of the exact model you're buying.

A "size" isn't the same length everywhere. Scarpa and La Sportiva sell in European sizes. La Sportiva's sizing page says its shoes are built on European half sizes, a smaller step than US half sizes. Scarpa puts one whole Euro size at 6.6 mm and one whole US size at about 8.4 mm. So a Euro half size is a smaller step than a US half size. When a brand tells you to go "one size down", check which scale it means.

How much climbing shoes stretch

Stretch depends on the upper. Sources agree on the order but not the amounts:

Upper REI La Sportiva Sport Conrad
Unlined leather Up to a full size About one full size (unlined, slip-lasted) Up to 1.5 sizes (leather)
Lined leather Half a size or less About half a size —
Synthetic Very little; softens slightly with use Not stated Up to half a size

What this means for sizing: if you're between two sizes in an unlined leather shoe, the smaller one may loosen to fit. A synthetic shoe will fit roughly as it does on the first day.

Shape and last

The last (the mould the shoe is built on) also matters:

Source: REI; La Sportiva.

Closure

Closure Strengths Trade-off
Laces Most adjustable: loosen for swelling or the walk-off, tighten at the toe for hard moves Slower on and off
Strap (hook-and-loop) Quick on and off, which suits the gym and bouldering Less fine-tuning
Slipper (elastic) Most sensitive and lowest profile, good in thin cracks and for training Least support

Source: REI.

Rubber and stiffness

Foot shape and volume

Trying on and buying online

When to resole or replace

Resole before the rand goes.

Shoe condition What it usually needs Source
Sole thin at the toe, line still visible, rand intact A half resole Climbing House (2023): $30–$40
Rand thinned or with a small hole A resole plus a rand repair or toe cap, which costs more. Climbing House says a rand repair can change the shoe's structure and limit future resoles Climbing.com; Climbing House
A large hole through the sole, rand or upper Usually replacement Climbing House

Allow time. One resoling guide says mail-in resoles can take up to six weeks in busy periods, so a second pair helps (Moja Gear).

Questions

How tight should climbing shoes be? Snug, with no dead space and your toes flat or slightly curled, but not painful. How snug depends on use. All-day trad shoes fit more loosely, and bouldering shoes fit tightest. Brands set their own size rules, so the same tightness can mean your street size in one brand and two sizes down in another.

Should beginners size down? Start with the fitting guide for your exact model. Ocún suggests starting at your street size for a beginner shoe, and Evolv's sizing page suggests one size up for an intermediate fit and two sizes up for a beginner fit. Neither guide says which size scale it means, so compare the same scale on that model's size chart. La Sportiva, which sizes in European sizes, suggests one to two sizes down for trad shoes. Follow the brand's rule, then check the fit.

Do climbing shoes stretch? Unlined leather can stretch by about a full size. Lined leather stretches by about half a size or less. Synthetic uppers stretch very little. See the stretch table above for each source's figures.

Do you wear socks with climbing shoes? Usually not. Shoes are designed for bare skin. If you plan to wear socks, for cold alpine routes for example, REI suggests going about half a size up.

When should I resole my climbing shoes? When the sole is thin at the toe and the line between sole and rand starts to fade, but before you climb on the rand itself.

Sources

  1. REI Expert Advice, "How to Choose the Best Rock Climbing Shoes"
  2. La Sportiva USA help centre, "How do I determine my rock climbing shoe size?"; La Sportiva USA, Sizing and technology, read 19 Nov 2026
  3. Scarpa fit tool (PDF), via Scarpa's retailer CDN; Scarpa size guide (Next Adventure / Backpacking Light, quoting Scarpa)
  4. Evolv: sizing page (evolvsports.com/sizing); Defy product page; REI product listings quoting Evolv's sizing notes
  5. Ocún, "How to choose the right climbing shoes for your foot shape"
  6. Sport Conrad, climbing shoe buyer's guide
  7. Climbing House: "How to Resole Climbing Shoes" (updated 29 Sep 2023); "When to replace shoes"
  8. Climbing.com, "Resoling and shoe care 101"; 99Boulders; Moja Gear